Ice cream is delicious. So is garlic. What about the two together?

Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream, an artisan ice cream company based in Columbus Ohio, did the seemingly unthinkable: the company incorporated garlic, onion, poppy seeds, and sesame into ice cream to created the hotly debated Everything Bagel flavor.

This controversial flavor was launched in January 2021, and is now making a comeback at the end of March. Whether this savory, buttery flavor sounds disgusting or incredible to you, it sold out in record time during its last launch.

According to Jeni’s reactions ranged from, “pretty damn good” to “not at all gross”. However, everyone could agree that it did indeed taste precisely like an everything bagel.

The Everything Bagel flavor will relaunch on March 21st on Jeni’s website and in-person scoop shops. Interested in joining the debate? Sign up here to get notified of the drop.